RepCabin

I'm tired of all these Medicare calls: Medicare sales

Objection guide: Medicare. Written by the RepCabin team. Updated .

The short answer

Agree first, because they are right. Say who you are and why you called in one sentence. Offer to put them on your do-not-call list right now. Ask permission for a single question, and stop completely on a no. Leave your number and hang up kindly.

Take the 3-minute sample call

Why buyers say it

Retirees field a steady stream of Medicare calls, many from sound-alike strangers and some from outright scammers. This buyer is not angry at you. They are worn out, a little afraid, and guarding their time, their phone line and their numbers.

How reps lose the deal on it

  1. They say "I understand, but this call is different." Every caller says that, and buyers hear one more stranger who skipped listening.
  2. They answer a request to stop with "Let me ask just one thing." Ignoring a plain no ends the call and hands the buyer a story about the caller who would not quit.
  3. They apologize, then pitch anyway. The apology was a crowbar, and the buyer knows it.

The steps, in order

  1. Say who you are and why you called in one sentence.
  2. Offer to put them on your do-not-call list right now.
  3. Ask permission for a single question, and stop completely on a no.
  4. Leave your number and hang up kindly.

Stronger lines to say

  • “You’re right to be tired of them. Here’s who I am and why I’m calling, and then it’s yours to decide: want me to take you off my list?”
  • “Say the word and your number goes on my do-not-call list right now. Or I have one question, and if the answer’s no, we’re finished.”
  • “Should you ever want somebody to read a plan letter with you and sell nothing, call this number. I won’t ring you again.”

A call that goes right

Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.

  1. BuyerPlease stop calling me. I get ten Medicare calls a day.
  2. RepThat sounds exhausting, and I’m sorry. I’m one of those calls, so here’s what I can do: take your number off my list right now, if you want.
  3. BuyerThen why are you still talking? And I trust none of you. Half are scams.
  4. RepYou’re right to be careful. Here’s how to tell me apart: you have my full name, my company and a number to ring back, and I won’t ask for your card or Medicare number on this call.
  5. BuyerFine. What do you want?
  6. RepOne question, and if you say no, we’re done. Has anyone you trust looked over what your plan covers in the past year?
  7. BuyerNo. My daughter said she’d get to it. I won’t do it with a stranger on the phone.
  8. RepGood plan. Let her. If she wants a second opinion, my number is yours. Thanks for hearing me out. I’m marking you do not call.

Same line, different meanings

The buyer saysUsually meansSay instead
“How did you get my number?”They fear someone sold their details and nobody asked them.“Fair question. I’ll tell you honestly what I know. If you’d rather not hear from me again, I’ll put you on my do-not-call list before we hang up.”
“Are you from Medicare?”They're confused about who is calling, or testing whether you will lie.“No, I’m not Medicare and I’m not the government. I’m an agent who works with certain plans, and I’ll tell you which ones before you say another word.”
“Take me off your list.”Exactly what it says, with no hidden invitation to talk on.“Done. Your number is off my list. Take care of yourself.”
“I get calls all day. I’m not interested.”Fatigue, not a verdict on anything you said.“Understood. May I leave you my number in case you ever want a second opinion, and then I’ll let you go?”

When to let the buyer go

The instant they say take me off your list, stop. Do not ask one last question, do not describe your offer, and never say "before you go." Confirm it is done, wish them a good day, and record it. If they linger and ask for your number, give it plainly.

Questions reps ask about it

What do I say when someone snaps that they are sick of Medicare calls?

Agree before anything else: "You're right, and I'm sorry." Give your name and reason in one sentence. Then hand over control by offering to remove them from your list. A caller who surrenders the steering wheel is the first that day who did.

Do I have to put them on my do-not-call list when asked?

Your compliance rules set the details, yet the stronger move is honoring it on the spot, no bargaining. Say "Done, your number is off my list." A rep who haggles over a request to stop makes the next caller harder to trust.

May I ask one more question after they say they're tired of calls?

Once, and only with permission: "May I ask one question, or would you rather I hang up?" If they choose hang up, do it warmly. If yes, keep the question short and honest. A second question after a no is how reps become stories.

How do I sound different from scam calls?

Give your full name and company early, say whom you represent and what you cannot compare, and offer a number for call-backs. Never claim to be Medicare or the government. Skip card and Medicare numbers on a first call. Calm, specific and easy to hang up on is the opposite of a scam.

What objection handling works when buyers hang up within ten seconds?

Shorten your opening. Sentence one is your name and reason, sentence two asks permission. Anything longer sounds like the calls they dread. If they hang up anyway, that was their decision, and you leave them alone.

Should I call back later after they say they are tired of calls?

Only if they ask. A buyer who vented and then agreed to one specific callback gave you permission. One who simply sighed did not. When in doubt, mark the number and leave it alone. Respect now is worth more than another attempt later.

Hear a buyer push back

The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.

Take the 3-minute sample call

The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.