Will my doctor take this plan?: Medicare sales
The short answer
Never say yes from memory. Get the doctor's full name and office town. Search this plan's directory while the buyer listens. Report exactly what it shows. Then ask the buyer to phone the front desk and confirm the plan by its full name before deciding.
Take the 3-minute sample callWhy buyers say it
For a Medicare buyer, a doctor is the plan. Years in one waiting room built trust, and a plan that severs it is worthless at any premium. Buyers also know somebody who heard yes and got billed, so this question tests whether you tell the truth.
How reps lose the deal on it
- They say "Yes, most doctors take it." Most is not hers. A surprise bill or an out-of-network referral lands on the buyer, with your name attached.
- They check the family doctor and stop. A heart specialist, eye doctor and surgeon each carry the same question, and the buyer discovers gaps at appointments.
- They treat a directory as gospel. It is a snapshot from some earlier day, and when the front desk disagrees, the buyer remembers who promised.
The steps, in order
- Get the doctor's full name and office town.
- Search this plan's directory while the buyer listens.
- Report exactly what it shows.
- Then ask the buyer to phone the front desk and confirm the plan by its full name before deciding.
Stronger lines to say
- “Good question, and I won’t guess. Give me the doctor’s full name and the town of the office, and I’ll search this plan’s directory while you’re on the line.”
- “Who else do you see? Specialists, the eye doctor, anyone you’d hate to lose. I’ll check each one.”
- “Here’s what the directory shows. Directories aren’t always current, so please call the office and ask whether they accept this exact plan by full name. If they say no, that’s your answer, and I’ll respect it.”
A call that goes right
Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.
- BuyerI’ve seen one doctor for years. Will my doctor take this plan?
- RepI won’t guess about that. What’s her full name, and which town is the office in? I’ll search while we talk.
- BuyerShe’s my family doctor, here in town. I also see a heart specialist across the county line.
- RepGive me both. Okay, your family doctor shows up. The specialist is listed too, but under a different address than you gave me.
- BuyerSo that’s a yes?
- RepIt’s a listing, not a yes. Directories lag behind real offices. Please phone both and ask whether each accepts this plan, naming it in full.
- BuyerSounds like homework. Just tell me yes so we can move on.
- RepI could say yes and be wrong, and you’d learn it in a waiting room. Hear it from the front desk instead. Want the plan’s exact name and the question written out slowly?
Same line, different meanings
| The buyer says | Usually means | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| “My doctor says she doesn’t accept that kind of plan.” | A different plan was once refused, and now every plan looks refused. | “Which plan did the office name? Different plans, different answers. Let’s search this one, then you can ask the office by name.” |
| “I only care that my doctor stays.” | Loyalty outranks price, perks and anything else you could say. | “Then doctors come first and everything else second. Who do you see, and who would hurt to lose?” |
| “What about my cancer specialist?” | Treatment is underway, so any change feels dangerous. | “That’s my first check, and I’ll report plainly. Ask that office about this plan and referrals too. Change nothing until both answers agree.” |
| “How do I know you’re telling the truth?” | Someone before you said yes and was wrong. | “Don’t take my word. I’ll name exactly where I’m looking, and you confirm with the office yourself.” |
When to let the buyer go
If the buyer's doctor is not covered and the buyer says that doctor is staying, stop. Say this plan is not right for them, and that hearing it now beats a first bill. Leave them one question for any plan's rep: is my doctor in your directory today?
Questions reps ask about it
Should I tell a Medicare buyer yes if the directory lists their doctor?
Say what the directory shows, never what will happen. Add that listings can be stale and the office has final say. A listed doctor plus a front desk call is a real answer. A promise from you is not one, and it costs you trust the first time a bill arrives.
What if the doctor is missing from the directory but the buyer swears the office accepts the plan?
Neither argue nor agree. Say you cannot find the doctor, and ask the buyer to have the office confirm the exact plan name. Written confirmation is best. If the office says no, believe their own front desk over any screen, and say so out loud.
How do I respond when a buyer says their doctor told them not to change?
Respect it and ask what was actually said. Often the doctor meant a different plan, or just warned about hassle. Offer to look this one up and hand the buyer a question for the office. Never suggest the doctor is mistaken.
Do hospitals, labs and pharmacies need the same check?
Yes. A surgeon operates at one hospital, blood work goes to one lab, pills come from one counter. Collect every name before answering anything, so no hole appears after a decision. Treat each as its own yes or no, and say which ones you could not confirm.
What objection handling examples work when a buyer will not move because of a specialist?
Start with the specialist: "Who is it, and how long have you gone?" Check that practice first and report plainly. When it fails, say this plan is wrong for them and offer other plans you can compare. Honesty at this moment is the whole sale.
What do I say when a buyer asks me to call the doctor's office for them?
Offer help, but keep the buyer central. Your compliance rules decide what you may verify yourself. Either way, the buyer should hear the front desk confirm it. Suggest they phone with the plan's name written down, and offer a three-way call if your rules allow it.
Related objections
Hear a buyer push back
The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.
The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.