I can get it cheaper online: insurance sales answers
The short answer
Agree they can find lower numbers, then compare the same coverage, not the same price. Ask to see the online quote. Walk the limits, deductible and exclusions side by side. Tell them honestly where the online option wins, and let them choose.
Take the 3-minute sample callWhy buyers say it
The buyer typed their details into a form, three minutes later a price appeared, and now your quote looks like the expensive one. A number on a screen is concrete, and your explanation is not yet. They are not against you. They are comparing a price to a conversation, and the price is winning because nobody has shown them what the price leaves out.
How reps lose the deal on it
- They attack online quotes, saying those policies do not pay when it counts. The buyer has no evidence of that and hears a rep running down the competition out of fear.
- They drop the price without asking what the other quote includes. The buyer learns the first number was negotiable and trusts both numbers less.
- They offer to beat any quote before they have looked at one. The buyer hears a promise nobody can keep and a rep who has not read the page in front of them.
The steps, in order
- Ask to see the online quote.
- Walk the limits, deductible and exclusions side by side.
- Tell them honestly where the online option wins, and let them choose.
Stronger lines to say
- “You probably can, and I’d rather you hear that from me. Do you have the quote handy? I’d like to put the same limits and deductible next to mine.”
- “Price is one line on the page. Let’s look at what each quote says if the claim is bigger than you’d expect, and whether they say the same thing there.”
- “If the online quote fits you better once we compare, take it, and I’ll tell you what to check before you sign. If mine fits better, I’ll show you exactly why.”
A call that goes right
Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.
- BuyerHonestly, I saw a price online that’s quite a bit lower than yours.
- RepThat happens a lot, and online is a real option. Can you tell me what that quote says for the deductible and the main coverage limits?
- BuyerI didn’t look at those. It showed me a price and I stopped there.
- RepUnderstandable, the price is what the page leads with. Would you read me those two lines if I read you mine, so we’re looking at the same thing?
- BuyerOkay. But I still think I’m better off with the cheaper one. Why pay more?
- RepYou might be. If the lines match and the only difference is price, the cheaper one is the better buy and I’ll say so. If they don’t match, you’re comparing two different things.
- BuyerAlright, the deductible is higher on theirs. And one of the limits is lower.
- RepThen you know what the price difference is made of. It’s your call either way. I’ll write the two side by side in an email and you pick.
Same line, different meanings
| The buyer says | Usually means | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| “My nephew says everything is cheaper online.” | A trusted person told them, and they won't hear you until the claim is tested. | “He’s right about plenty of things. Let’s take one quote and one of mine and read them the same way, and see where they differ.” |
| “I got a quote from an online company for way less.” | Sticker shock, and perhaps a coverage mismatch they have not noticed. | “That’s a big gap, and big gaps usually mean something is different. Can you read me what it says for the deductible and the limits?” |
| “I don’t need an agent, I can do it myself.” | They don't see what a person adds until something goes wrong. | “You can, and plenty of people do fine. An agent earns the spot when you have a question at claim time or renewal. If you don’t want that, the online route is reasonable.” |
| “Last time I switched online and it worked out fine. Why not again?” | A repeat shopper who has already succeeded and expects a repeat. | “Then you already know how to shop, and I won’t pretend otherwise. Let me show you what I’d look at before you switch again, like anything that changed since last time.” |
When to let the buyer go
If the buyer has compared the coverage line by line and still prefers the online quote, thank them for doing the work. Tell them what to check when they sign, such as limits, deductible and cancellation terms, and that you are glad to look over their policy anytime. Leave them with that offer and your number, and let the sale go.
Questions reps ask about it
What is the best response when a customer says they can get insurance cheaper online?
Agree that they may well find a lower number, then move the conversation from price to coverage. Ask to see the quote, and read the deductible, limits and exclusions side by side with yours. Whoever the buyer picks, they will have decided with facts. That is the only response that holds up when the buyer goes home and checks.
How do I compare quotes without trashing the competition?
Stick to what is written on the two documents: limits, deductibles, exclusions, and what happens at renewal. Say "let's read the same lines on both." Never speculate about how another company treats claims. A buyer who hears you criticize others starts wondering what you are covering for.
What if the online price really is lower for the same coverage?
Say so out loud. Then name what you offer that the page does not: a person who picks up the phone, someone to review the policy when life changes, help at claim time. Let the buyer decide whether that is worth it to them. If price is the whole story for this buyer, a clean loss is better than a bad win.
Can I match an online quote?
Only if your company's rules allow it and the coverage is truly the same, which you can only judge after reading both. Never promise a match before you check. Say "let me see what I can do inside my own rules," then come back with a straight answer, even when the answer is no.
What do I say if they already bought online?
Do not undo their decision. Ask what they were hoping for, tell them you are glad to look over the policy if they ever want a second pair of eyes, and mention a renewal or a life change as a natural time to talk. You are not losing a sale, you are keeping a door open.
What objection handling works on a buyer who thinks all insurance is the same?
Ask them to read you two lines from their own policy, the deductible and one coverage limit. Then read yours. Two policies priced a few steps apart often differ on exactly those lines, and the buyer sees it in their own voice. Showing is stronger than telling, and it keeps you out of an argument.
Related objections
Hear a buyer push back
The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.
The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.