RepCabin

Can you match the other estimate?: roofing sales

Objection guide: Roofing. Written by the RepCabin team. Updated .

The short answer

Ask to see the other estimate before you answer. Compare it line by line: tear off, decking, underlayment, flashing, vents, cleanup, and warranty. If the jobs match, say what you can honestly change. If they differ, show where. If it is the same job for less from a roofer they trust, let them go.

Take the 3-minute sample call

Why buyers say it

Matching is a negotiation request dressed as a question. The buyer holds a piece of paper with a lower number and wants to know if you will blink. Some buyers want a lower number. Others want permission to pick you without feeling they overpaid, and a fair answer gives them that.

How reps lose the deal on it

  1. They say yes without reading the other estimate. The buyer gets the lower price and a bad feeling about every number the rep gave before.
  2. They say we do not negotiate. True or not, the buyer hears a wall, and the other roofer has a phone and an open calendar.
  3. They cut the price and keep the same job description, so something silently vanishes: the underlayment, the permit, the cleanup. The buyer finds out in month two.

The steps, in order

  1. Compare it line by line: tear off, decking, underlayment, flashing, vents, cleanup, and warranty.
  2. If the jobs match, say what you can honestly change.
  3. If they differ, show where.
  4. If it is the same job for less from a roofer they trust, let them go.

Stronger lines to say

  • “Show me what you have got. If I cannot match what it covers, I do not want to match what it costs.”
  • “Let me go through it with you. Tear off, decking, underlayment, flashing, vents, cleanup, warranty. If the two jobs are the same, I will tell you what I can and cannot do.”
  • “If theirs is the same job for less and you trust them, hire them. If it is not the same job, I will show you where it differs on paper and you decide.”

A call that goes right

Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.

  1. BuyerI have another estimate that’s lower than yours. Can you match it?
  2. RepMaybe. Can I see it? I want to know if we are pricing the same roof.
  3. BuyerSure. It just lists a total and says shingles, labor, cleanup. Nothing more detailed than that.
  4. RepThat is thin. Ask them if the total covers tearing off the old layer, replacing any bad decking, new underlayment, flashing and vents. If they say yes to all of it, it is the same job.
  5. BuyerYou’re dodging. Just give me the same number and I’ll sign right now.
  6. RepI will not sign you into something we cannot compare, and I will not drop the price just because you asked. If they answer yes to everything, hire them. If any answer is no, call me and we will work out what to change.
  7. BuyerOkay. I’ll ask them tomorrow and call you after.
  8. RepGood. I will write the same list on mine so you can see both side by side. What day are you meeting them?

Same line, different meanings

The buyer saysUsually meansSay instead
“I just need you to match it and I’ll sign.”Price is the only gate between you and a yes.“If I can honestly match it, I will. Show me the page so I can see what it covers, and I will give you a straight yes or no today.”
“My neighbor told me what he paid and it was less.”An anecdote has become the benchmark, and the roofs are probably not the same.“Good information. Was it the same size roof, and did it include tear off and decking? Roofs vary a lot house to house, so I would like to know how close it is.”
“I’ll go with whoever is lowest.”The only tool anyone gave them is the total, so they use it.“Then let us make sure you are comparing the same job. Ask each roofer these five questions. If mine is the higher number for the same job, go with the lower one.”
“The other company said their price drops if I sign this week.”A deadline is pressing on them, and they want to know if you will do the same.“That is their call. Ask yourself why a price moves for a signature. Mine does not move for a deadline, and the job will look the same next week.”

When to let the buyer go

When the buyer has the same-job comparison in front of them and picks the lower roofer, say that is a fair decision and mean it. Offer to answer questions about the work they hire out, leave your written scope, and ask them to call if the job changes once the crew opens the deck. Do not leave a parting shot about the other roofer.

Questions reps ask about it

What do I say when a roofing customer asks me to match another estimate?

Ask to see it. Do not say yes or no before you have read it. Go through it line by line with the buyer, naming what it covers and what it leaves out. Then your answer is honest: the same job, a different job, or a better offer. That is the whole rebuttal.

Should a roofing salesperson price match?

Not blindly. A match on a different scope is a loss that looks like a win. If the jobs are the same and you hold the authority, change one concrete thing and say why. Otherwise explain where the other price comes from and let the buyer choose with full information.

What if the customer won't show me the other estimate?

Ask them to read you the line items, or send a photo with the other roofer's name covered. If they refuse, hand over a short list of questions for the other roofer. Say you cannot match what you cannot read, and you will gladly go through it whenever they are ready.

How do I find out what is missing from the other roofer's estimate?

Look for what is not named: tear off, decking replacement, underlayment type, flashing, drip edge, ventilation, cleanup, permit and warranty terms. Have the buyer ask the other roofer about each. Do not guess what was left out; let them hear it from the person who wrote it.

What can I offer instead of a lower price when a customer asks for a match?

Trade scope or terms. Offer a different shingle line, a later start, a smaller project, or a payment schedule inside your company's rules. Say what changed and why. A trade keeps your first number honest and gives the buyer a real choice, instead of a price that bends when pushed.

Hear a buyer push back

The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.

Take the 3-minute sample call

The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.