RepCabin

Let me think about it and call you back: life sales

Objection guide: Life insurance. Written by the RepCabin team. Updated .

The short answer

Say thinking it over is a smart move, then ask what they will be weighing. Answer that one question now if you can. Offer to put a ten minute callback on the calendar with that question as the agenda. Let them choose between calling you or hearing from you.

Take the 3-minute sample call

Why buyers say it

A person asked to protect their family in one phone call, with a stranger, wants the call to end more than they want an answer. "Let me think about it" is polite and costs them nothing. Underneath there is often one question, the price, a spouse or the health form they dread, and nobody has said it out loud.

How reps lose the deal on it

  1. They say "of course, call me anytime" and hang up. The buyer hears a door left open with nobody holding it, and the callback never comes from either side.
  2. They squeeze in a second pitch right on top of the objection. The buyer only asked for time, and now hears that nobody was listening.
  3. They guess the objection for the buyer: "is it the price?" The buyer takes the exit that ends the call fastest, says yes, and the real question stays buried.

The steps, in order

  1. Answer that one question now if you can.
  2. Offer to put a ten minute callback on the calendar with that question as the agenda.
  3. Let them choose between calling you or hearing from you.

Stronger lines to say

  • “Of course, a decision like this deserves time. What’s the one question you’ll be turning over? If I can answer it in a minute, you’ll have more to think with.”
  • “Let’s put ten minutes on the calendar so it doesn’t slip. What day suits you, and what should I have ready by then?”
  • “Would you rather call me when you’re ready, or should I call you Thursday evening? Either is fine. If you’ve decided against it by then, just say so and that’s the end of it.”

A call that goes right

Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.

  1. BuyerThis is a lot to take in. Let me think about it and call you back.
  2. RepSure, and you should take the time. So I can make it easier, what’s the one part you expect to be thinking about?
  3. BuyerI guess whether this is the right amount. And I haven’t talked to my wife yet.
  4. RepBoth fair. I can help with the amount right now, so when you talk to her it’s one clear thing and not a pile of numbers. Want to do that first?
  5. BuyerI’d rather just sleep on it. I don’t like deciding on a phone call.
  6. RepTotally fine. Nothing has to be decided on this call. I’ll send the one page we went over, and you pick a day for a ten minute call with her on it.
  7. BuyerMaybe next week, once she’s seen it. I’ll message you when we’ve talked.
  8. RepPerfect. And if it’s not the right fit once you two talk, I’d rather hear no than have you feel you owe me a call.

Same line, different meanings

The buyer saysUsually meansSay instead
“I’ll call you if I’m interested.”A polite exit. They do not expect to call.“That works, and if you’re not interested, that’s okay too. Can I ask what would make it interesting, so I don’t waste your time or send you things you don’t need?”
“Let me run it by my husband and I’ll call you back.”A real second decider, not a stall.“That’s the right call. Can I send a one page summary he can read in two minutes, and would a short call with the two of you be easier than carrying it between you?”
“Let me see how my finances look at the end of the month.”A budget worry dressed as a calendar date.“Smart. What number would you want to see by then? Let me write it down so you know when the answer is yes and when it’s no.”
“Let me do some research online first.”They want to verify you, and they will compare.“Please do. Three things are worth comparing: the amount, the length, and whether the rate stays the same. I’ll email them so you’re comparing like with like.”

When to let the buyer go

When the buyer says they will be in touch, take them at their word. Say you are glad you talked, leave your number and a one page summary, and make clear there is no deadline and no pressure. Send one kind note a week later. After that, let their silence be an answer and keep your name as the one rep who did not chase.

Questions reps ask about it

What should I say when a life insurance buyer says they will think about it and call me back?

Welcome it, then ask what they expect to be thinking about. People who say this almost always have one specific question in mind. Answer it if you can, and if you cannot, schedule the callback around it. An open "call anytime" rarely turns into a call.

How do I find out what they are really weighing?

Ask open, then give them easy examples. "Some people are weighing the cost, some want to talk to a spouse, some dread the health questions. Which is closest for you?" Naming the common ones gives the buyer permission to pick one honestly, instead of saying the polite thing and leaving.

Should I ask for a specific callback time?

Yes, and offer two options so the buyer picks. People keep a time they chose. Say what the call is for, such as ten minutes on the one question they mentioned. If they decline a time, ask which they would prefer, you calling or them.

What if the buyer refuses to give me a time?

Respect it. Leave a one page summary of what you covered and tell them you will try once, a week or so later, then ask if that is all right. After that, the next move is theirs. Check your own contact rules before you plan any more attempts, and do not exceed them.

How many times should I contact someone after "I'll call you back"?

Once after the agreed time, with a short written note, and then only if they reply. A rep who calls three times in a week is chasing, not following up. Stay inside your own compliance rules on contact frequency, and treat silence after a respectful note as an answer.

What is a good opening for the callback itself?

Start with the exact question they said they were weighing. "Last time you were thinking about whether this is the right amount. Did you get anywhere with that?" works because it shows you remembered. Opening with "just checking in" gives them nothing to answer and an easy way to say they are still thinking.

Hear a buyer push back

The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.

Take the 3-minute sample call

The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.