Life insurance is too expensive: life sales
The short answer
Ask what monthly number feels comfortable, then build the coverage backward from it. Say the price comes from the amount and length of coverage, which they control. Show one smaller amount or shorter term that fits inside their number. If nothing fits, say so and stop.
Take the 3-minute sample callWhy buyers say it
A policy has no price tag in the buyer's head until the rep says one, and then it becomes a monthly bill for something they hope never happens. Most of the time "too expensive" means "bigger than the number I had in mind." Sometimes it is a real budget wall, and you have to find out which before you say another word.
How reps lose the deal on it
- They defend the number. Explaining why the premium is fair tells the buyer the price is fixed, and the buyer hears a wall go up between them and the conversation.
- They jump to the cheapest product on the sheet without asking what the policy is for. The buyer hears a rep hunting for something small enough to sign, and coverage that no longer does its job is no bargain.
- They compare the premium to a coffee habit or a phone bill. A buyer counting every dollar hears someone who never asked about their month.
The steps, in order
- Say the price comes from the amount and length of coverage, which they control.
- Show one smaller amount or shorter term that fits inside their number.
- If nothing fits, say so and stop.
Stronger lines to say
- “I hear you. Before I say anything else about price, what monthly number would feel comfortable? Let’s start there and see what it buys.”
- “The price is mostly two dials, how much coverage and for how many years. Let me turn them down until it fits your number, and I’ll show you what you give up each time.”
- “If nothing I can show you fits inside your budget, I’ll tell you that straight. You’ll have lost ten minutes and nothing else.”
A call that goes right
Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.
- BuyerI looked at the number you gave me and honestly, it’s too expensive. I wasn’t expecting that.
- RepI’m glad you said so. What were you expecting? Give me a monthly figure that would feel comfortable and I’ll work backward from it.
- BuyerMaybe a third of that. We’re already stretched with the kids’ activities and the car payment.
- RepOkay. The price is mostly two things, how much coverage and for how many years, and I can lower either one. What is this mainly supposed to cover for your family?
- BuyerThe mortgage, mostly. But a smaller amount feels like I’m doing it halfway.
- RepThat’s a fair worry, and I won’t pretend a smaller amount does the same job. Here’s what it covers and what it leaves out, so you can see the gap yourself.
- BuyerEven that is more than I can add right now. Let me just hold off.
- RepThen holding off is the right call. I’ll send what we went through, no strings. If your month loosens up, call me and we’ll start where we left off.
Same line, different meanings
| The buyer says | Usually means | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| “That’s more than I pay for my car insurance.” | They anchored on a bill they already know, and this one feels like a luxury next to it. | “I get why you’d compare it. Car insurance protects the car and this protects people, so let’s decide what you want it to protect and size it from there.” |
| “Whole life is way too much money.” | They were shown a permanent policy when a shorter one might have fit their need. | “Then let’s not start there. Tell me how many years you need the coverage, and I’ll put a shorter option next to it so you can see why they are priced so differently.” |
| “My budget is already tight, I can’t add anything.” | A real wall, not a negotiating move. | “Then I’d rather not add a bill. Tell me what you pay each month and I’ll say if anything small fits, or if the honest answer is no for now.” |
| “My friend said it should cost a lot less than that.” | A number from someone else is anchoring them, and they do not know what moves a price. | “It might, and it’s worth knowing why. Price moves with age, health, amount and term, so tell me what your friend has and we’ll compare the same things.” |
When to let the buyer go
When the buyer says the smaller amount still does not fit, or mentions the budget a second time, the call is over for now. Say you would rather they keep their money than carry a bill that strains the month. Send what you went over in writing with your direct number, and ask if you may check back in a few months. Then do.
Questions reps ask about it
What is the best response when a buyer says life insurance is too expensive?
Do not defend the price. Ask what monthly number would feel comfortable, then work backward by adjusting the amount of coverage or the length of the term. The buyer moves from judging a number you picked to shaping one with you, and you find out fast whether the problem is the product or the budget.
How do I tell sticker shock from a real budget problem?
Ask what they expected to pay. Sticker shock carries a lower figure and some curiosity about the gap. A budget wall sounds flat: nothing is left at month's end. If it is a wall, stop adjusting figures and offer a smaller or later step. Pushing past a wall costs you the buyer's trust.
Should I lower the coverage amount or the term first?
Ask what the policy is meant to cover. A mortgage means matching the term to the loan, so trim the amount first. Young children may call for a shorter term instead. Lay both out together, say what each one gives up, and let the buyer pick.
What do I say when they compare the price to what a coworker pays?
Say it may well be a fair comparison and ask what the coworker has. Age, health, amount and term all move the price, so two people can pay very different numbers for good reasons. Ask them to find out the details and bring them back. Never guess at the other policy's terms.
Is it a good idea to break the price into a daily cost?
Skip it. Buyers recognize the trick, and a daily figure shrinks the cost below the bill that actually arrives. Say the monthly amount and let it stand. Plainness about money earns trust for everything you say after it, and a buyer who feels tricked about small things assumes the worst about big ones.
What if they still say it is too expensive after I lower the amount?
Believe them. Say that holding off is sensible, send what you went over in writing, and ask if you may check back in a few months. A buyer allowed to say no comfortably is the one who calls when the month loosens.
Related objections
Hear a buyer push back
The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.
The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.