Insurance only approved part of it: roofing sales
The short answer
Don't argue with the adjuster or promise more money. Ask to see the approval line by line. Compare it against your written scope and mark every difference. Offer your photos and measurements for the homeowner to send the insurer. Then price the approved work and the full job separately, so the homeowner picks.
Take the 3-minute sample callWhy buyers say it
The letter came back covering less than the roof needs. This homeowner now holds two numbers that don't match: one from the company they pay monthly, one from a stranger on their driveway. Which is wrong? They don't know, and they're bracing for a bill on whatever falls between.
How reps lose the deal on it
- They claim the insurer lowballed it and the rest will get covered. Nobody can know that. The homeowner hears a stranger promising somebody else's money.
- They trash the adjuster. Now the homeowner sits between two parties fighting over a roof, and doing nothing becomes the quietest exit.
- They quote the whole job without explaining what the approved amount buys. No visible gap, no decision, and whichever roofer explains it clearly gets the call.
The steps, in order
- Ask to see the approval line by line.
- Compare it against your written scope and mark every difference.
- Offer your photos and measurements for the homeowner to send the insurer.
- Then price the approved work and the full job separately, so the homeowner picks.
Stronger lines to say
- “That’s frustrating, and I’m not going to guess why they landed there. Can you read me what the approval covers, line by line, and I’ll mark where it differs from what I wrote up?”
- “I can’t tell you what your insurer will do. What I can give you is my photos, my measurements and my written scope, and you decide whether to send them back and ask for another look.”
- “Let me price it two ways: only what they approved, and the whole job. Then you can see the exact difference and choose which road you want.”
A call that goes right
Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.
- BuyerInsurance only approved the back slope. The front is still a mess and they say it’s not covered. Now what?
- RepRough letter to open. Can you read me what it lists, the lines and areas? I want it beside what I found up there before I say anything.
- BuyerBack slope and some flashing. Nothing on the front. You told me the whole roof had to go.
- RepMy scope includes the front slope, with photos. I can’t say the insurer is wrong. I can show you what they approved, what they left out, and what each piece costs alone.
- BuyerSo should I push them for the front, or just pay it myself? I don’t want a fight with my insurance company.
- RepI won’t tell you to fight anyone. You can send them my photos and ask for another look, fix only what’s approved, or do all of it. Those are your three roads, and none of them is wrong.
- BuyerI still don’t get why I’d pay you for the front when they might come around.
- RepYou may not have to, and I won’t ask you to decide today. If they answer, I’ll re-price from whatever they say. Want both prices by email tonight, and a call from me Thursday?
Same line, different meanings
| The buyer says | Usually means | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| “They approved a repair, but I need a whole roof.” | Two professionals disagreed, and they're deciding whom to believe. | “Both can be true. They priced what they saw. I priced what I measured. Let’s set the documents side by side and find exactly where they split.” |
| “They only paid for part and I can’t afford the rest.” | This is a money problem, not a roof problem. | “Then we find the smallest repair that stops the leak and price it alone. Tell me what fits this month, and I’ll show you what waits.” |
| “Insurance said the rest is just wear and tear.” | Someone told them it's age, it stings, and they want to know if it's true. | “I can’t rule on what your policy covers. I can show you what I see up there and write it plainly. If you believe it’s storm damage, take my photos back to them and ask.” |
| “My neighbor’s whole roof got paid for. Why not mine?” | It feels unfair, and they want someone to explain it. | “Houses and damage differ, and I can’t compare yours with theirs. Let’s look at your approval and your roof. If something doesn’t add up, your insurer is the one who can explain it.” |
When to let the buyer go
If the homeowner takes the approved amount, fixes only that, and is done, believe them. Price the approved work cleanly, put in writing what it leaves undone, and say you're glad to look at the rest whenever they want. Leave the scope and your number behind. A smaller job with trust intact beats a bigger one with resentment.
Questions reps ask about it
What is the best response when a homeowner says insurance only approved part of the roof?
Ask to see the approval line by line, beside your written scope. Mark each difference: a slope, flashing, decking, ventilation, drip edge. Price approved work and the full job separately. Homeowners stop fighting a mystery and start choosing between two clear numbers.
How do I handle a homeowner who asks me to get the insurer to pay the rest?
Hand over dated photos, measurements and a written scope. The homeowner decides whether to send them and request another review. Promise nothing about the outcome, and never speak for the homeowner unless your company's rules and their written permission allow it.
Should I offer to cover the deductible or the gap to win the job?
No. Don't offer to absorb a deductible or a difference, and don't hint that something can be arranged. Money moving between you and a homeowner is a question for your company's rules, so check before speaking. Quote the real price plainly. Homeowners remember who suggested a shortcut.
What if the homeowner only wants to fix the approved part?
Price it cleanly and say in writing what it leaves undone: the slope untouched, the flashing not replaced, the leak path still open. Don't sell against their choice. A homeowner who knows exactly what the smaller job covers can return for the rest without feeling tricked.
How do I read an insurance estimate with a homeowner on the phone?
Ask for a photo of each page. Check the roof area covered, which lines say repair and which say replace, what's listed for flashing and edges, and what the homeowner owes. Say back what you see in plain words. Leave coverage opinions to the insurer.
What do I say when they ask whether the insurance company will reconsider?
Say you don't know, and that nobody outside the insurer does. Tell them they can request a second look, and that dated photos plus a written scope strengthen the request. Offer to re-price the day an answer arrives. Honest, and it keeps you the person they call next.
Related objections
Hear a buyer push back
The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.
The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.