I don't trust insurance agents: life insurance sales
The short answer
Do not defend the profession. Agree that the doubt came from somewhere, then ask what happened. Say what you will and will not do on this call, including that they can say no. Offer to explain the product in plain words with nothing to sign. Let them set the pace.
Take the 3-minute sample callWhy buyers say it
There is usually a story behind it: a relative sold a policy that lapsed, a call that arrived at the wrong moment, a document nobody explained, a visit that would not end. The buyer does not distrust you personally. They distrust the role, someone who is paid when they sign. Their guard is reasonable, and they are watching whether you behave like the person in the story.
How reps lose the deal on it
- They protest, "I'm not like those other agents." Every agent says it, and the buyer hears the first line of a sales pitch.
- They rush to prove themselves with credentials and a presentation. The buyer wanted to be heard first and now feels like a lead being worked.
- They sidestep the comment and carry on with the script. The buyer just said the most important thing on the call, was ignored, and starts looking for a way to hang up.
The steps, in order
- Agree that the doubt came from somewhere, then ask what happened.
- Say what you will and will not do on this call, including that they can say no.
- Offer to explain the product in plain words with nothing to sign.
- Let them set the pace.
Stronger lines to say
- “That’s fair, and plenty of people feel that way. You don’t have to trust me. I’d just ask you to watch what I do on this call.”
- “Can I ask what happened? I’d rather know what you’ve been through than guess.”
- “Here’s how I work. I explain everything in plain words, you can say no at any point, and nothing gets signed today. If I say something that doesn’t sound right, stop me.”
A call that goes right
Example exchange. The buyer and the call are fictional.
- BuyerI’ll be honest, I don’t trust insurance agents. My dad got burned.
- RepThank you for saying it straight. If you’re open to it, what happened to your dad?
- BuyerHe signed up over the phone and it didn’t work out the way they told him. Nobody picked up when we called to ask.
- RepThat’s a terrible thing to find out when your family needs an answer. I won’t tell you I’m different. I’ll tell you how I do this, and you can judge it as we go.
- BuyerFine. But you get paid when I sign, so why would I believe anything you say?
- RepI do get paid if you buy, and you should know that. So ask for everything in writing, read it, and take it to someone you trust before you decide. I’m okay if the answer is no.
- BuyerThat’s not what I expected an agent to say.
- RepThen let me ask what you’d want to understand first, and I’ll explain only that. If it isn’t for you, we stop there. Which part feels most important?
Same line, different meanings
| The buyer says | Usually means | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| “Agents just want a commission.” | They assume your advice follows your pay, and they want to see whether you will admit it. | “I do get paid if you buy, so you should know how. I’ll tell you. Then you decide whether what I’m saying sounds like it serves you or me.” |
| “I got a call right after my husband passed, and I haven’t answered an agent since.” | A painful moment was handled badly, and the hurt is bigger than any sales objection. | “I’m sorry. That shouldn’t have happened to you. I won’t ask for anything today. If you’d like, I can explain what I do, and you can decide in your own time.” |
| “I’ve been lied to by an agent before.” | A specific betrayal sits behind it, and they need transparency more than a good pitch. | “Then I’d like to be the one who doesn’t. Tell me what they said that turned out wrong, and I’ll tell you what I can and can’t say about this.” |
| “I don’t buy anything over the phone.” | It is a personal rule that protects them, and it is not about you. | “That’s a smart rule. Then let’s not buy anything. I can send you the plain facts in writing, and you decide whether to call me, someone else, or nobody.” |
When to let the buyer go
If the buyer says they want nothing from an agent, believe it. Say you understand, that you were glad they were honest, and that they never owe you a reason. Give them your number and one sentence they can use on any agent: ask how you are paid. Then let them end the call.
Questions reps ask about it
What do I say when someone tells me they don't trust insurance agents?
Agree the doubt came from somewhere, and ask what happened. Skip credentials. Hear the whole story, say it sounds awful, then state how this call will run: plain words, nothing signed today, stop me any time. Then run it exactly that way.
Should I tell them I'm not like other agents?
No. Every agent says it, so it weighs nothing. Show it instead. Explain how you are paid when asked, drop the jargon, urge them to read everything and take their time, and sound relaxed about a no. They decide how different you are from the next five minutes.
How do I rebuild trust when a previous agent burned them?
Let them tell it without correcting a detail. Then make small promises you can keep right now: I will explain every term, I will put it in writing, I will not ask for a decision today. Every kept promise is a deposit. Invite them to check you, not believe you.
What do I say when they ask how I get paid?
Answer directly, in plain words, within your company's compliance rules. Asking about pay is a test of whether you dodge. Answer without flinching and you pass what most people in your seat fail. Not sure how to explain it? Learn it before your next call.
What should I never say to a buyer who doesn't trust agents?
Never "trust me," "I'm different" or "you'd be foolish not to." Never hurry them, lean on their family's situation, or talk past a no. Anything that resembles the story they just told you proves them right, and you rarely get a second chance on the same call.
Related objections
Hear a buyer push back
The free call uses a sample scenario. Answer out loud, hear the buyer push back, and try a stronger answer.
The buyer is AI and the company is fictional. Want the whole team practicing? See pricing.